Omega vs DNA report

mainman · Jan 17, 2004, 08:33 PM

I would like to congrat you cowboy for your awsome work bud!!! Very nice article, it sure cleared alot of things up. Very interesting read indeed.

drakesteakn · Jan 17, 2004, 10:31 PM

Great work neon cowboy and roadee. It shows now what drivers are best with a clean review.

BetrayerX · Jan 18, 2004, 12:41 AM

Quote:

Why does Guru3D.com host DNA's drivers and not Omega's you ask? Simple, we can't do it all as hosting files in terms of bandwidth is extremely expensive. Since Omega drivers are widely supported we tend to give the smaller guys a chance. In this case it is DNA and for NVIDIA StarStorm.

It's easy for Hilllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllbert to say this. This just helps in his own personal agenda to end up discrediting ATI.....post the crappiest drivers...let people complain.

KS and Hilllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllbert are two of the same kind.

....have no bandwith....BAH!

Nice Article NEON!
I appreciate people who say things the way they are, contrary to the clown quote above.

ixce · Jan 18, 2004, 03:18 AM

i liked this review a lot but there arn't a lot of cons to omega's drivers?? and i use DNA drivers currently with no problems and omega i used but for like 10 min so i coudnt test them out. but i would really like to see some other people do unbiased benches to confirm neon's results because i could really use the extra frames

***Zardon*** · Jan 18, 2004, 04:31 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by ixce
i liked this review a lot but there arn't a lot of cons to omega's drivers?? and i use DNA drivers currently with no problems and omega i used but for like 10 min so i coudnt test them out. but i would really like to see some other people do unbiased benches to confirm neon's results because i could really use the extra frames

Another review different site

cmac · Jan 18, 2004, 07:53 AM

First off I would like to say that I visit this site and Rage3d a number of times a day. Everytime I log on actually. I've loved all the info I've gotten from them. Saying that I'm also on the DNA Beta team. I tried to get on ATI'S but did not make it. I would like to say that I've used everyone's drivers at one time or another and I never have a problem with any of them (none that I could not get resolved anyway). I respect Omega's work and used his exclusifily when I used to have a NVIDIA CARD and have used his ati drivers too. I have even sent him a donation in the last month (along with one to this site and Rage3d and KS too) to help him out as I feel it is good to have options out there. That said I don't know the whole story and don't want to regarding KS. I was just interested in beta testing and he needed help. This is strictly my opinion too. I've only had one problem with his drivers and that was getting them to install on my 9800XT and he worked with me and we got it resolved and that is what I'm supposed to do as a beta tester. Besides that I don't have any problems with them. They run everything great and look great too. As to how he handles getting his drivers to the public is this. He is constantly tweaking stuff and giving us revisions after he releases a set up until the time ATI releases a new set. Then he goes over their new set and compares it to the last beta set he has and makes any changes he needs and sends us new beta and if we have no problems with them he releases it. So as far as the time frame goes he isn't waiting for Omegas to come out to release his. We are getting new ones from him all the time during the month. Do I agree with his attitude sometimes. No I don't and I have told him that also. Like I said it is only my experience and I have no doubt people have had problems with his stuff as some people have problems with Omegas and the Official ones too. Like I always said not everything works the same way on any given Rig.

Thanks cmac

Dawnrazor · Jan 18, 2004, 12:24 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Malus
Very well written. However, I could see KS just blaming the outcome on bias instead of his shoddy work. Just keep your cool and don't let him try anything stupid.

Why are you surprised, given both DriverHeaven's and the tester's history with KS and the DNA drivers? I'm NOT saying the tests were faked, but given the animosity that exists of course some people are going to asume it. And I do have a question in the back of my head if DH would have treated the results differently if they had shown the DNA set to be better.

For the record I used the DNA drivers once, they fixed a problem with the Control Panel not wanting to install, (I posted about it here and on Rage3D at the time), ran good but had bugs that prevented me playing a couple of my favorite games, so they didn't stay on my system to long. I'm using Omegas now which is what I usually use

Dawnrazor · Jan 18, 2004, 12:29 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Crash Override
oh really?

then why have I been banned multiple times for posting out against KillerSneak on the forums anytime he did bashing on Omega?

or wait that isnt something we should talk about is it?

If KillerSneak wasnt spending 90% of his time getting his butt kissed by Spyre and a couple other staff I wouldnt be sitting here having been banned like 5 times in the last 6/7 months.

this might better belong in a PM. If so just tell me and I will edit the post to say something else and kick this in a PM to Kombatant

As I recall, the last time was for threatening one of the mods...You even started a thread in one of the forms here boasting about it.

Dem2k · Jan 18, 2004, 05:29 PM

A good review. I don't want to get into the major details, but i think you should edit the spelling part. Why you ask? Well for one we all know he lives in Holland, Netherlands and infact English is not his/there native langauge. Its a second langauge and it would depend on his age if he is fluent in it or not. (but judging from what hes posted in the past "pfft")

Other then that thumbs up, though the conclussion has raised eyebrows.

edit: well after browsing through his forums what i just said is completely invaild. So leave it in.

digitalwanderer · Jan 18, 2004, 05:47 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by BetrayerX
It's easy for Hilllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllbert to say this. This just helps in his own personal agenda to end up discrediting ATI.....post the crappiest drivers...let people complain.

KS and Hilllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllbert are two of the same kind.

....have no bandwith....BAH!

Nice Article NEON!
I appreciate people who say things the way they are, contrary to the clown quote above.

"Hilllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllbert" is still slaying me!

***Zardon*** · Jan 18, 2004, 05:57 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Dawnrazor
And I do have a question in the back of my head if DH would have treated the results differently if they had shown the DNA set to be better.e

not quite sure I understand the question. please elaborate.

Dawnrazor · Jan 18, 2004, 06:49 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Zardon
not quite sure I understand the question. please elaborate.

If the tests had shown that the DNA drivers walked all over Omegas would it still have been hyped all over the front page? Or simply buried in a thread somewhere like the link to that German site that apperently showed them to be the best. I say apperently cause I don't speak German and could only go by the graphs, the text coulda been calling them buggy pieces of shit for all I know.

I'm not trying to defend KS, just pointing out why not everyone is so accepting of the test results...Kinda like asking Saddam Hussien to judge Bush or vice versa...

Chaos · Jan 18, 2004, 06:55 PM

I think if DNA had walked all over Omega, they would have had to report that....

They would have to state that DNA also had to be doing something over and above Omega, but that is not what happened

just my opinion though cause Neon does tend to tell it like it is

You should have seen the rants he went on when he was converting from Nvidia

Dawnrazor · Jan 18, 2004, 06:57 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Chaos
I think if DNA had walked all over Omega, they would have had to report that....

They would have to state that DNA also had to be doing something over and above Omega, but that is not what happened

just my opinion though cause Neon does tend to tell it like it is

I didn't say they wouldn't, I just questioned whether the results would have been hyped like this, or buried in a thread somewhere.

toddsmack2k · Jan 18, 2004, 07:02 PM

No matter what the results would have been we would have posted them up for anyone to see just like what we did. You can read what you want into the bias we supposedly have here. We dont do it that way here at Driverheaven. We show the facts and the truth!

~~Crash Override~~ · Jan 18, 2004, 07:28 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Dawnrazor
I didn't say they wouldn't, I just questioned whether the results would have been hyped like this, or buried in a thread somewhere.

You dont know Mike (Neon Cowboy) very well then do you?

If his results had bared out that the DNAs had won and DH even had the slightest thought about suppressing it he would have raised holy hell.

btw check your PM for the real story on what happened at Rage3D

Dawnrazor · Jan 18, 2004, 07:37 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Crash Override
You dont know Mike (Neon Cowboy) very well then do you?

If his results had bared out that the DNAs had won and DH even had the slightest thought about suppressing it he would have raised holy hell.

btw check your PM for the real story on what happened at Rage3D

I'll read it soon as I post this...

I never said DH wouldn't post the results. I questioned whether they'd get front page status or simplied buried or briefly noted as just another set of benchmarks. After all it's human nature to hype results you agree with, not ones that mean eating a large plate of crow...

~~Crash Override~~ · Jan 18, 2004, 07:46 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Dawnrazor
I'll read it soon as I post this...

I never said DH wouldn't post the results. I questioned whether they'd get front page status or simplied buried or briefly noted as just another set of benchmarks. After all it's human nature to hype results you agree with, not ones that mean eating a large plate of crow...

I didnt say anything about not posting.

I said that if they tried to "suppress the results."

Suppression has many levels. The one I usually associate with it is also called downplay.

Thats probably what I should have said in the first place.

Basically, what if they had promised Mike front page and didnt give it to him because the results didnt bare out what they wanted to see?

He'd be ripping this site a new one.

Me and him used to have bouts over ATi vs. nV until he joined the light side.

Also if you really look closely at his results. FPS vs Image Quality ATi is the actual winner. For pure IQ Omega wins.

If DNA drivers had been better in any of these areas he would have posted it just that way. I mean the pictures to me speak for themselves.

Hes not the type to go pussyfooting around the results. He's brutally honest, even if its not what he wants to believe.

Dawnrazor · Jan 18, 2004, 08:12 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Crash Override
I didnt say anything about not posting.

I said that if they tried to "suppress the results."

Suppression has many levels. The one I usually associate with it is also called downplay.

Thats probably what I should have said in the first place.

Basically, what if they had promised Mike front page and didnt give it to him because the results didnt bare out what they wanted to see?

He'd be ripping this site a new one.

Me and him used to have bouts over ATi vs. nV until he joined the light side.

Also if you really look closely at his results. FPS vs Image Quality ATi is the actual winner. For pure IQ Omega wins.

If DNA drivers had been better in any of these areas he would have posted it just that way. I mean the pictures to me speak for themselves.

Hes not the type to go pussyfooting around the results. He's brutally honest, even if its not what he wants to believe.

I didn't notice anything saying he'd been promised frontpage, if I missed it in all the posts my bad. If they promised him it results unseen then that was a damn fair move on DH's part and a comendable one.

Also I never questioned his results, I use the Omegas myself...Just a what if that popped up given the history between the parties involved.

~~Crash Override~~ · Jan 18, 2004, 09:30 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Dawnrazor
I didn't notice anything saying he'd been promised frontpage, if I missed it in all the posts my bad. If they promised him it results unseen then that was a damn fair move on DH's part and a comendable one.

Also I never questioned his results, I use the Omegas myself...Just a what if that popped up given the history between the parties involved.

actually he was

Id have to dig through the threads for quite some time to find it but he was told once it was done that it would be posted as news

That always means front page.

Also since I get tired of sending PMs :P Mr. K still hasnt written me back since I told him about Mr. Rs actions and showed him the stuff. He's been on the forum quite a few times since then.

KillerSneak fans at Rage?

The_Neon_Cowboy · Jan 18, 2004, 09:37 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by Dawnrazor
If the tests had shown that the DNA drivers walked all over Omegas would it still have been hyped all over the front page? Or simply buried in a thread somewhere like the link to that German site that apperently showed them to be the best. I say apperently cause I don't speak German and could only go by the graphs, the text coulda been calling them buggy pieces of shit for all I know.

That site as never posted here except by killer sneak and his inner circle. Killersneak is quite fluent in German ad believed by many to be directly involved in that review by more then just a handful of people. Also the test results the German site was way off in contrast to what was found when I tested. To me I question weather the benchmark score decided with the pc off or on. Either they didn't know what they were doing; they did something quite wrong or pulled the results from this air we may never know. By what I could see it wasn’t done in a controlled environment. Also it wasn’t in a professional manner that they took a lot of their screenshots by taking photo with a digital camera.
They got many small things wrong for example the release dates. I'm looking at it now.
they dont go into much detail or mention alot of stuff thats apparent...

~~MonarchX~~ · Jan 18, 2004, 10:09 PM

This review meant to bring DNA down. Its a complete lie, the 16bit Z-Buffer is a complete lie, and could totally screw with all the scores, the settings are definately like the ones I get from RadLinker. And just listen to what he says about VSYNC - it may cause artifacts?! Tearing - YES, not artifacts, but in a game like CoD - does it run 100+ FPS on all the computers?! OH HELL NO! Not with AA and AF! This is THE most biased review there can be on the internet.

mainman · Jan 18, 2004, 10:27 PM

Dont worry Cowboy, you did a great review of the drives, time will tell your right cuz i think people will do their own reviews, and you are gonna be proven right.

toddsmack2k · Jan 18, 2004, 11:56 PM

Quote:

Originally posted by MonarchX
This review meant to bring DNA down. Its a complete lie, the 16bit Z-Buffer is a complete lie, and could totally screw with all the scores, the settings are definately like the ones I get from RadLinker. And just listen to what he says about VSYNC - it may cause artifacts?! Tearing - YES, not artifacts, but in a game like CoD - does it run 100+ FPS on all the computers?! OH HELL NO! Not with AA and AF! This is THE most biased review there can be on the internet.

It is a lie huh? Well then I ask you to put up or shut up! Prove what you are saying or stop with your non sense. You cannot, so stop with the insults and professing what you percieve to be true.

Constructive criticism is welcome here but not shooting off at the mouth with BS.
I do know you have been warned about your conduct recently and I expect you to heed the warning now.

DDM_Reaper20 · Jan 19, 2004, 01:43 AM

Quote:

Originally posted by Dawnrazor
If the tests had shown that the DNA drivers walked all over Omegas would it still have been hyped all over the front page? Or simply buried in a thread somewhere like the link to that German site that apperently showed them to be the best. I say apperently cause I don't speak German and could only go by the graphs, the text coulda been calling them buggy pieces of shit for all I know.

I'm not trying to defend KS, just pointing out why not everyone is so accepting of the test results...Kinda like asking Saddam Hussien to judge Bush or vice versa...

Do you have the link handy? I speak German, I'd be interested to have a peek at that review.