Hmmmm......???
Why is it that every review mentions "issues with targeting"? The way it's done seems perfectly reasonable to me.
You target what your character is facing. Now if you have trouble keeping up with how your perspective is lined up, that isn't totally a game malfunction. I think your expectations are just too high. And besides, you don't always have enough energy to able to constantly use your force powers. That's WHY you have a Light Sabre! Also I have to opine that this game is not just about "Force Powers", the light sabre combos are also very cool. So when you get caught up in the deficiencies of that one aspect, you fail to be truly objective in your evaluation.
The "tearing" you mention on the Xbox is probably an artifact that is related to the LCD display you're using. I've been playing on a Plasma and I haven't seen this happen. I also have the output for the Xbox set to 1080p - though my Vizio 32" Plasma is only capable of 1080i/720p. My guess is that I might get slightly better performance with a 720p setting in games, but I also watch downloadable shows that benefit from the higher setting (don't ask me why...!?! It just makes them appear "sharper" on my TV).
And finally, I have to disagree with your comments on replay value. I've almost completed the game, and I'm just getting used to the control scheme. See I'm more accustomed to PC gaming controls, so every new game on the Xbox 360 requires some adjustment on my part. I figure future play-throughs will be more enjoyable, while also allowing me to select a higher difficulty setting and experiment with different character builds. I guess some of the high expectations people have are Lucas Arts fault. They've hyped up the force power features with slogans like "May the Force blow your mind". And some of you are lazy and want the game to be super easy, seconds after you begin playing "Starkiller".
This is my take on the game: If you like Star Wars, and want to take a walk on the Dark Side, you'll enjoy this game. Just give yourself some time to get used to "how things work".